A new controversy has erupted over the alleged dual role of Minister Ashok Chaudhary in Bihar politics. The Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) has intensified its attack on the Nitish-Samrat government over this issue. RJD’s national chief spokesperson and Rajya Sabha MP Prof. Manoj Kumar Jha has alleged that Bihar government minister Ashok Kumar Chaudhary, while serving as a member of the Legislative Council, accepted the position of assistant professor at AN College under Patliputra University, violating constitutional provisions related to the position of profit.
He demanded that Chief Minister Samrat Chaudhary immediately dismiss Ashok Chaudhary from his ministerial post and begin the process of terminating his Legislative Council membership. At a press conference held at the Karpoori Auditorium located at the RJD state office, Prof. Manoj Jha said that the seriousness of the entire matter has increased after the comments from Raj Bhavan.
He claimed that the Governor’s Secretariat report made it clear that Ashok Chaudhary used his influence as a member of the Legislative Council to secure a lecturer job and then applied for leave the very next day after taking charge. On this occasion, former minister Mr. Israel Mansuri, RJD’s state chief spokesperson Shakti Singh Yadav, Legislative Council member Kari Mo. Souheb and state spokesperson Ejaz Ahmed were also present.
Ashok Chaudhary became Assistant Professor while serving as MLC
Prof. Manoj Jha said that Ashok Chaudhary became an assistant professor at AN College while serving as a member of the Bihar Legislative Council. He also questioned the use of the name ‘Dr. Ashok Kumar’ in the appointment process. RJD alleges that at the time of his appointment, Ashok Chaudhary was a member of the Legislative Council and is currently an MLC and a minister in the state government.
It is worth mentioning that Ashok Chaudhary joined as an Assistant Professor in the Department of Political Science at AN College, Patna, under Patliputra University, on February 17, 2026. The very next day, he submitted an application related to leave or lien. This issue was later raised in the university’s syndicate meeting.
Controversy escalates due to Raj Bhavan’s comment
The matter reached the syndicate meeting of Patliputra University on August 19, 2026. Questions were raised at the university level regarding Ashok Chaudhary’s leave and lien requests. After that, the matter was sent to the Governor’s Secretariat for guidance. In a prepared remark on October 31, the then Additional Chief Secretary to the Governor, Deepak Kumar Singh, said that the provision to grant lien benefits to assistant professors appointed during the probation period does not apply in this case.
The comment also raised the question of how the relevant provisions view the status of a person being appointed as a teacher in the university while already serving as an MLA or Legislative Council member.
The Raj Bhavan comment also raised the question of whether the post of Assistant Professor is considered a position of profit. It stated that whether the salary was actually taken or not is not the sole decisive factor; The right to salary or financial benefits associated with the position can also be important. Amid this controversy, Raj Bhavan has sought legal opinions from Bihar’s Advocate General SD Sanjay on the matter. At present, the final opinion of the Advocate General and the final decision of the competent authority in this matter have not been publicly released.
Ashok Chaudhary also presented his argument
Ashok Chaudhary has also responded to this controversy. Calling the Raj Bhavan’s remarks inspired, he said that the provisions related to university service and membership in the legislature are not being interpreted correctly in their case.
Ashok Chaudhary argues that Section 68(2) of the Bihar State University Act provides special leave protection to university teachers and employees if elected as members of the legislature. He also said that there are examples of liens being granted during probation periods in other universities, and the law should be applied equally to everyone.
Thus, on one side there are comments from Raj Bhavan and allegations from RJD, while on the other, Ashok Chaudhary is arguing in favor of provisions related to his appointment and leave. Now, the Advocate General’s opinion in this matter is considered crucial.
Manoj Jha cited the case of Jaya Bachchan as an example
Prof. Manoj Jha also cited the 2006 Jaya Bachchan case to support his allegations. He said that at that time, Jaya Bachchan’s Rajya Sabha membership was terminated due to the position of profit. RJD says that action should also be taken under constitutional provisions in Ashok Chaudhary’s case.
What does Article 191 of the Constitution say?
The matter of the office of profit is linked to Article 191(1)(a) of the Indian Constitution. According to it, if a person holds a position of profit under the central or state government that is not legally exempted from disqualification, they may be disqualified from remaining a member of the state assembly or legislative council. However, Article 191 of the Constitution also clarifies that merely being a minister does not mean a person is considered to hold a position of profit under the government. In other words, a ministerial position does not automatically disqualify you on this basis.
In Ashok Chaudhary’s case, the main legal question is whether the post of Assistant Professor at AN College is a lucrative position and what is the legal status of appointment and contribution to that position while serving as a member of the Legislative Council.
Article 192 of the Constitution provides the procedure for deciding questions related to the disqualification of a member of the state legislature. In such cases, the question goes before the Governor, and the Election Commission’s opinion is sought before the decision. Therefore, membership is not automatically terminated merely by a political party’s demand or an initial comment from Raj Bhavan.
RJD also attacks Chief Minister Samrat Chaudhary
Prof. Manoj Jha directly targeted Chief Minister Samrat Chaudhary, saying that considering the legal aspects of the entire matter, the government should take immediate action. He warned that if there is a delay in action, it will be assumed that the Chief Minister stands with those who violate the law.
RJD has demanded that Ashok Chaudhary be removed from his ministerial post and that an immediate decision be made under constitutional procedure regarding his membership in the Legislative Council. Now everyone’s attention is on the Advocate General’s legal opinion, the Governor’s Secretariat’s further action, and the constitutional process. If any adverse decision is made in this matter, it could seriously affect Ashok Chaudhary’s membership in the Legislative Council. So far, no final order has been issued regarding the termination of his membership.












