The Punjab and Haryana High Court has held that the date on which the process for compassionate appointment was initiated, rather than the date of issuance of the formal appointment order, would be relevant in determining eligibility for the Old Pension Scheme (OPS) in cases covered by the applicable instructions.
Allowing a writ petition filed against the State of Haryana and other respondents, Justice Harpreet Singh Brar held that three petitioners could not be denied OPS benefits merely because their appointment orders were issued in January and February 2006, after the relevant cut-off date of October 28, 2005, when their claims had already been initiated and forwarded by the competent authorities before that date.
Pre-cut-off date initiation of claims decisive
The court noted that the fathers of all three petitioners had died in harness much before October 28, 2005, and their claims for compassionate/ex-gratia appointment had also been initiated before the cut-off date.
Recording the chronology, the court noted that the first petitioner’s claim was forwarded by Narnaul District Education Officer on March 3, 2003. The second petitioner submitted the application on May 3, 2005, which was forwarded on June 21, 2005, while the third petitioner submitted the application on May 30, 2005, which was forwarded on August 23, 2005.
Justice Brar observed that the subsequent appointment orders issued in January and February 2006 were “merely the culmination of the process which had commenced prior to the introduction of the New Defined Contributory Pension Scheme”.
Justice Brar further held that the petitioners “cannot be made to suffer on account of the delay in issuance of formal appointment orders”, particularly when their appointment claims had already been initiated and forwarded by the competent authorities before the cut-off date.
Justice Brar ruled that the respondents’ objection that they had joined government service after January 1, 2006, was “of no avail”. The petitioners were accordingly held entitled to the benefit of the Office Memorandum/Instructions dated May 8, 2023, subject to fulfilment of the other conditions stipulated therein.
Six weeks to exercise OPS option
Justice Brar directed the petitioners to exercise the requisite option for switching over to OPS within six weeks of receiving a certified copy of the order. The respondents were directed to process their claims and extend all consequential benefits within a further six weeks of receiving the options.
“The respondents shall also undertake the requisite procedural formalities, including transfer of the respective NPS corpus of the petitioners to their GPF accounts, in accordance with the applicable procedure,” the Bench added
Clarifying the scope of the relief, the court said the benefits would remain subject to fulfilment of all other applicable conditions under the May 8, 2023 instructions and relevant rules.













