SC orders authorities to trace World War II veteran’s heirs after Centre alleges ‘fraud’ in pension claim

As the Centre alleged possible fraud in an application filed before the Armed Forces Tribunal (AFT) seeking pension benefits on behalf of ex-rifleman Govind Rawat — a World War II veteran, the Supreme Court on Wednesday directed the Army to make every effort to ascertain his legal heirs.

A Bench led by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant directed the Senior Superintendent of Police and the SHO concerned to provide full assistance to Army officials in identifying his legal heirs and asked the Army to submit a report.

The order came after the Centre alleged that an application seeking war-injury pension in Rawat’s name was filed before the AFT more than a year after his death in January 2019 and nearly two years before the AFT granted him the pension.

Additional Solicitor General Archana Pathak Dave told the Bench that Rawat died on January 17, 2019 but the pension case before the AFT was filed in his name on July 27, 2020. The authorities discovered the discrepancy while seeking bank documents, including a cancelled cheque, to comply with the pension order.

The Bench said it would examine if it had been misled about the war veteran in whose favour it had upheld a war injury pension order.

“If fraud has been played on court, then we have to detect it,” CJI Kant said, adding an inquiry was necessary to investigate the alleged fraud. The authorities should have exercised due diligence when the case was filed in the veteran’s name, he said.

Rawat, a former rifleman of the British Indian Army sustained injuries while serving in Italy during World War II. He was medically discharged from service in April 1947 and subsequently received a disability pension.

On June 4, 2021, the Lucknow Bench of the AFT allowed his claim for war injury pension. The AFT rejected the Centre’s contention that the relevant pension policy did not cover injuries sustained before Independence.

The Centre moved the Supreme Court against the AFT’s order. On October 17, 2023, the top court dismissed its application for condonation of delay and the appeal.

Raising questions over the institution of the original proceedings and the identity of those who pursued the claim, the Centre has moved the top court again.