PCS exam under cloud: Aspirants move high court alleging rigged result, demand CBI probe into PPSC selection

Several candidates who appeared in the Punjab Civil Services (PCS) and Allied Services examination have approached the Punjab and Haryana High Court, seeking quashing of the selection process and an independent investigation into alleged irregularities in the recruitment conducted by Punjab Public Service Commission (PPSC).

The petitions challenge the recruitment initiated through an advertisement dated January 3, 2025, and the mains result declared on November 4, in which 751 candidates were shortlisted. One of the principal objections concerns clusters of consecutive roll numbers in the shortlisted candidates’ list. The petitioners have alleged that “26 clusters of three or more consecutive roll numbers appear in the selection list, accounting for 86 shortlisted candidates”. They have further identified 118 clusters of consecutive roll numbers comprising 270 candidates, a figure which, according to the note, the commission has acknowledged.

The petitioners have also questioned the absence of category-wise bifurcation in the result, alleging that different roll numbers and registration numbers in the preliminary and mains examinations made comparison difficult.

Another major challenge concerns changes in eligibility conditions after the advertisement. The original clause required candidates to have passed matriculation with Punjabi as a compulsory or elective subject or an equivalent examination. However, a subsequent public notice permitted candidates who had studied Punjabi at graduation level to claim equivalence. The petitioners have questioned the commission’s authority to make this change, contending that the relevant statutory rule vests the power to specify an equivalent examination in the government.

They have also alleged that candidates were permitted to submit multiple application forms and obtain multiple roll numbers. The amended condition stated: “However, in case a candidate fills multiple forms, he/she shall be issued multiple roll nos.”

The petitions further raise questions over alleged violations of prescribed age limits, repeated extensions of application deadlines, non-verification of Punjabi qualifications and the eligibility of candidates under reserved categories.

On the conduct of the mains examination, the petitioners have alleged that question-paper packets reached certain examination rooms “in an unsealed or broken condition”. They have also questioned changes in classrooms at one examination centre and alleged irregularities in the handling and evaluation of answer sheets.

A second group of petitioners has additionally raised allegations of conflict of interest, misuse of disability-related concessions and circulation of the result date and category-wise cut-offs on Telegram channels before their official declaration.

The petitioners have sought quashing of the entire selection process, an independent investigation by CBI or a special investigation team, scrutiny of the eligibility of all shortlisted candidates and a direction to keep further selection proceedings in abeyance. They have also sought that the complete recruitment record be sealed or summoned by the court.